The other day, I was reading ANN, as I normally do, and came across this story about some VC firm giving the anime streaming site Crunchyroll $4 million bucks to do what it does. Now, this wouldn’t be news, in all likelyhood, if it weren’t for the fact that the controversial Crunchyroll already charges for the ability to view things they don’t own, rationalizing it as charging for the bandwidth the high-quality streams use. Second, they charge to be able to download the fansubs they have on the server, which are the same ones you can get from an torrent tracker. Finally, a lot of what they do is illegal/grey market, especially the displaying of already-licensed material such as Azumanga Daioh. So, needless to say, they’re a bit scummy.
Now, I’m not going to pretend that such a service isn’t attractive, but the site basically plays out like a badly-run anime club. The forums are full of threads such as “When is ur bed time?” and “Which site do u go to watch anime,Crunchyroll,Veoh or Youtube“. Which should give you a hint about the community, if you ask me. But beyond that, this sets a bad trend. Now, I’m no darling cuddle-up of the anime companies. I think they’re morons who need to get their acts together before they go under. But a site like this is bothersome in another way: Rather than having fans who go out and become part of the “anime culture”, for what it is, they instead end up in “the bottom of the barrel”, an exclusionest area where intellegence and not acting like a moron are almost punished in a sense. The community is run in the exact wrong way a community is run: people who pay are given preferential treatment, people look up to those with high post counts (why do you think I use Vanilla? No post counts next to the posts.), and one-word posts are seen as no problem. Seriously, the place is more of a sewer than YouTube video comments. Now, granted, people would be morons on their own, but when a concentrated group of them like this happens, it creates a problem. Now, with Crunchyroll, and by extension its forums, being a well-known meeting place for fans, people are going to go there and think that this is how you should behave, or even worse, that all fans act like this. Now, granted, I’m being a bit extreme here. But this grants a kind of elevated status to the morons and dipshits, whereas the smarter fans are even more marginallized than they already are. A site like Crunchyroll is useless to anyone who knows enough to bother with torrents. Therefore, the only people who are going to go there are morons. Yes, you heard me, and I hope someone posts this on the CR forums. Not me, tho. I value my sanity too highly.